While someone purchases through the links posted on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Find how it works.

Evenflo Vs Graco Car Seat: Key Differences You Need To Know 

By Jennifer Ward

When it comes to ensuring the safety and comfort of your tiny tots while traveling, selecting the right car seat is of utmost importance. Today, we will explore the world of all-in-one car seats, specifically those designed to transition seamlessly from an infant car seat to a backless booster seat. While many all-in-one car seats seem similar at first glance, some key differences can significantly impact your choice. 

Two leading contenders in the all-in-one car seat category are the Evenflo Everyfit and the Graco 4Ever. These versatile car seats are designed to accommodate babies up to 120 lbs. and boast four different sitting positions to support your kids as they grow. While both seats recommend the same weight limits for each position, there are some differences that set them apart. Let’s get to know the key differences between the Evenflo Everyfit and the Graco 4Ever. 

Evenflo EveryFit 4-in-1 Review 

Evenflo EveryFit 4-in-1 Convertible Car Seat
Evenflo EveryFit 4-in-1 Convertible Car Seat

Evenflo’s Everyfit 4-in-1 convertible car seat is affordable and meets all the safety standards. This versatile car seat is 19 lbs. and is designed to adapt and grow with your kid for up to 10 years. This car seat can support from just 4 lbs. Up to 120 lbs. with four different sitting positions. The seat comes with added cushioning and fabrics that you can toss in the washing machine to ensure a clean and cozy ride for your little one. Besides, the EveryFit is also relatively easy to install and use. Overall, the Evenflo EveryFit 4-in-1 convertible car seat is a good option for parents looking for a comfortable and affordable car seat. 

  • Can be used in four different modes 
  • Lightweight & compact 
  • Affordable 
  • Easy to install and use 
  • 12 headrest positions 
  • No-rethread harness 
  • Meets all applicable safety standards 
  • 2 cup holder & removable snack tray 
  • Straps can be a bit difficult to tighten 

Graco 4Ever 4-in-1 Review 

Graco 4Ever DLX 4 in 1 Car Seat
Graco 4Ever DLX 4 in 1 Car Seat

Graco 4Ever DLX is a high-end premium car seat that weighs 22 lbs. This car seat can be used in four modes, like the EveryFit. The seat is comfy enough for your kid from 4 to 120 lbs. The cushions can be removed and machine-washed, which makes it easy to keep the seat clean. Their latch installation system makes connecting the car seat to the vehicle’s LATCH anchors easy. The connectors are color-coded and have a one-click attachment for a quick and secure installation. Overall, the Graco 4Ever is a luxurious option for parents looking for a car seat that can grow with their kid (up to 10 years) and provide excellent safety and comfort features. 

  • Four seating modes 
  • 10 headrest positions 
  • 6 recline positions 
  • No-rethread harness 
  • Easy to install 
  • Simultaneous headrest and harness adjustment 
  • Removable, washable cover 
  • 2 cup holders 
  • A bit heavy 

Evenflo Vs Graco Car Seat: Features Comparison

Features Graco 4Ever Evenflo EveryFit 4-in-1 
Car Seat Type  All-in-one All-in-one 
Car Seat Mode 
Weight Limit 4-120 lbs. 4-120 lbs. 
Age Limit Up to 10 years Up to 10 years 
Frame Durable Durable 
Recline Positions  
Machine Washable Cushion Yes Yes 
Cup Holder  Yes Yes 
Headrest Position 10 12 
Product Weight 22 lbs. 19 lbs. 
Installation Type Belt & LATCH Belt & LATCH 
Item Dimensions LxWxH ‎20 x 21.5 x 24 inches ‎22.25 x 19 x 32.5 inches 

Evenflo Vs Graco Comparision In Detail: 

Size & Weight Limit 

Evenflo EveryFit 4-in-1 Convertible Car Seat offers a versatile and top-rated solution for both infants and toddlers. It boasts four distinct modes: a rear-facing harness infant car seat, a forward-facing harness car seat, a high-back booster, and a no-back booster seat. With a wide weight range of 4 to 120 lbs. and a height limit of 57 inches, this car seat ensures a safe and secure journey for your kid for up to ten years. 

Graco 4Ever 4-in-1 stands out as a highly sought-after car seat in the market due to its exceptional longevity. This car seat also offers four distinct configurations like the EveryFit: rear-facing, front-facing with a harness, high-back booster, and backless booster. It can accompany a kid from as light as 4 lbs. to all the way up to 120 lbs. with a height limit of 57 inches. 

Winner: It’s a tie. Both the car seats have the same weight capacity and height limit. 


Evenflo EveryFit car seat takes care of your kid’s hot and sweaty issues with its innovative airflow mesh fabrics. These fabrics work like a charm to keep your kid cool and comfortable, even on scorching summer days. This car seat boasts a luxuriously soft seat cushion, a plush headrest, and padded armrests, all of which work together to ensure a cozy journey for your kid. Additionally, it features a 12-position adjustable headrest and four reclining positions.  

The padding in the Graco 4ever car seat is adequate, but I think it could be denser for better comfort. Thicker padding can provide that extra plushness that makes long drives more enjoyable. The fabric used in this seat has a relatively coarse weave. While it’s not uncomfortable, your baby might find it less soft against his/her skin. On a positive note, the base bottom is smooth and designed to protect your vehicle seat. However, Graco 4ever has less headrest (10) but more reclining positions (6) than the EveryFit.  

Winner: Evenflo EveryFit. The seat of Everyfit is more comfortable than the Graco 4ever. 

Graco 4Ever DLX 4 in 1 Car Seat_ Comfort

Ease of Use 

The Evenflo Everyfit car seat is designed to be easy to use, even for parents new to installing car seats. The seat has a number of features that make it user-friendly, including SureSafe™ Installation System. This system includes easy-to-use connectors and a set of LATCH guides that help to improve proper installation by 2x (compared to standard LATCH installations). The headrest can be adjusted with just one hand, which makes it easy to get a proper fit for your baby. Besides, the harness can be adjusted without removing the seat from the car. 

The Graco 4ever car seat comes with an InRight LATCH system. This system makes connecting the car seat to your vehicle’s LATCH. The connectors are color-coded and have a one-click attachment for a quick and secure installation. The harness can be adjusted without removing the seat from the car, just like the EveryFit. The harness system allows you to simultaneously adjust the harness and headrest height with one hand. Moreover, the headrest can also be adjusted to accommodate your baby’s growth. 

Winner: It’s a tie. Both car seats have an easy installation system and adjustable headrests and harnesses. 

Ease of Use


The cover of EveryFit is machine washable. That’s a win, in my book, as cleaning becomes much easier. But there’s a catch – you’ll need to hang it to dry. It takes time, and you’ll have to wait before you can use your seat again. However, removing and replacing the cover is a fairly straightforward process.  

Graco 4Ever 4 in 1 car seat comes with a removable and washable cover. The cover is also easy to clean and can be machine-washed and dried. Moreover, removing the cover is a breeze, and you don’t need to go through the hassle of uninstalling the seat. This convenience is thanks to their new feature, ‘ Rapid Remove Cover’. Graco claims the cover can be removed in 60 seconds, and I’ve found it true! 

Winner: Graco 4ever. Although both car seat covers are machine washable, the 4ever dries faster than the EveryFit. 

Washable Cover


Evenflo Everyfit car seat is easy to install with the LATCH installation system. Here are the steps: 

  1. Locate the LATCH anchors in your vehicle. 
  1. Attach the lower anchor connectors of the car seat to the LATCH anchors in the vehicle. 
  1. Tighten the LATCH straps to secure the car seat in place. 
  1. Adjust the recline angle of the car seat according to the manufacturer’s instructions. 
  1. Ensure a secure installation by checking for minimal movement of the car seat. 

The Graco 4Ever car seat can be installed using your vehicle seat belt. Here are the steps: 

  1. Thread the vehicle seat belt through the belt path of the car seat. 
  1. Buckle the seat belt and ensure it is securely fastened. 
  1. Remove any slack from the seat belt by pulling it tight. 
  1. Adjust the recline angle of the car seat according to the manufacturer’s instructions. 

Winner: It’s a tie. With the proper instructions and a little practice, you can install these car seats correctly and ensure maximum safety for your kid. 

Why Should You Choose Evenflo EveryFit 4-in-1? 

Evenflo EveryFit 4-in-1 is a great choice for parents looking for an affordable car seat that can grow with their kids and provide excellent comfort and safety features. This car seat is relatively affordable (under $250), especially compared to other car seats offering the same features. Moreover, the car seat is also designed to protect children in a variety of crash types, including side-impact collisions. 

Why Should You Choose Graco 4ever 4-in-1? 

Graco 4Ever 4-in-1 is a premium car seat for parents that offers versatility, comfort, safety, and convenience. It’s a top choice if you want a reliable and long-lasting car seat that ensures your kid’s well-being and comfort throughout the journey. This car seat is designed with multiple safety features that meet industry standards and provide peace of mind to parents on the road. 

Final Words 

Evenflo Everyfit and the Graco 4Ever car seats offer more than just protection; they come with a slew of convenient features and adaptability to ensure your little one’s comfort and safety. They can seamlessly adapt as your kid grows, from infancy to that exciting stage when they’re ready for a backless booster. Both of these car seats also meet stringent safety standards. While the Evenflo Everyfit is praised for its budget-friendly affordability, the Graco 4Ever, on the other hand, offers a broader array of features with premium comfort. So, the choice between these two car seats ultimately depends on your specific needs, budget, and preferences. 

Related Posts:
Nuna Rava Vs Britax One4life
Graco Tranzitions Vs Nautilus
Graco Tranzitions 3 in 1 Review

Leave a Comment